• ქართული
  • Українська
  • Русский
Donate Now
No Result
View All Result
Independence Avenue Media
  • Home
  • Spotlight
  • Interview
  • Deep Dive
  • Forged by War
  • The Shatterbelt Brief
  • Video
    • Ukraine Stories
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Our Board
Independence Avenue Media
  • Home
  • Spotlight
  • Interview
  • Deep Dive
  • Forged by War
  • The Shatterbelt Brief
  • Video
    • Ukraine Stories
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Our Board
No Result
View All Result
Independence Avenue Media
Home > The Shatterbelt Brief > Commentary: Not Quite Yalta on the South China Sea

Commentary: Not Quite Yalta on the South China Sea

The Trump-Putin-Xi summit came to nothing, writes Brian Whitmore writes in this week’s Shatterbelt Brief.

Brian Whitmoreby Brian Whitmore
November 19, 2026
REUTERS

REUTERS

A A
Summarize with ChatGPTShare on X

The Shatterbelt Brief is a weekly column by Brian Whitmore examining the shifting political and geopolitical dynamics of Eastern Europe and Eurasia. The views expressed are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect those of Independence Avenue Media.

On the eve of the much-hyped trilateral “superpower” summit in Shenzhen, Kyiv had a strong message for those who think they run the world.

Just hours before Chinese President Xi Jinping hosted U.S. President Donald Trump and Kremlin autocrat Vladimir Putin at a lakeside villa in China’s southeastern tech hub, Ukraine launched its third attack in four days on the Kerch Strait Bridge linking Russia and occupied Crimea.

The attacks partially collapsed the bridge, severing road traffic and indefinitely halting rail traffic between Russia and the illegally annexed Ukrainian peninsula — and in the process exposing major gaps in Russia’s air defense network, while creating a severe logistical bottleneck for Russian forces in southern Ukraine.

A visibly shaken Putin looked like he was about to cry (really, watch the video) as he whined on about Ukraine striking “an exclusively civilian target” and implausibly claimed that the bridge “was not used to transport military hardware or equipment.” He also vowed a “far more painful response” and ruled out any further negotiations on even a limited ceasefire to end the war he started — and is losing.

For his part, Trump, who has been persistently repeating Kremlin talking points as he has tried to forge an end to the war on terms favorable to Moscow, was true to form. He reportedly told NBC News that the Russian leader was “extremely upset” with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy over the bridge strike and that he “understood Putin’s feelings about this.”

So much for Yalta on the South China Sea. In the end, the much-hyped summit, which took place on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum, turned out to be a big nothingburger.

Before the meeting, Vladimir Medinsky, Putin’s bombastic chief negotiator, told Russian state television that Moscow’s goal was to establish “a new, modern Yalta and Potsdam,” referring to the allied conferences in 1945 that divided Europe into Soviet and Western spheres of influence and consigned the continent’s eastern countries to decades of subjugation to the Kremlin.

Zelenskyy retorted sharply, telling NBC News: “Big countries always think they can make decisions about the future of the whole world. This is a huge mistake, absolutely. You cannot make decisions about a country, even a small one, without that country.” To claim otherwise, he added, is “just rhetoric.”

And then he hit Putin’s beloved bridge, a symbol of Russia’s imperial expansion.

Following Trump’s departure from Shenzhen, Politico reported that the president called in to a meeting of Ukraine’s European allies from Air Force One, and remarkably claimed that Putin was serious about peace, suggested that Zelenskyy was the obstacle and pressed for an end to the billions of dollars of aid the Europeans are providing to Kyiv.

But the Europeans held firm.

At a press conference after they met, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said the defense aid to Ukraine was “to enable peace negotiations in the first place and to conduct them from a position of strength.” And Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk publicly mocked Trump for referring to Putin as “my friend” in Shenzhen with two social media posts: in one, he wrote “God, protect us from such friends” and in another he posted a photo of himself, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham and Zelenskyy smiling with the caption “true friendship.”

True friendship. pic.twitter.com/ukp5fPp6Rn

— Donald Tusk (@donaldtusk) November 19, 2026

So despite all the hype about Yalta II (and I have been guilty of it as well) it turns out that 2026 is not exactly 1945. “The rest of the world is not powerless. Unlike in 1945, others have agency, if they choose to use it,” Ivo Daalder, who served as President Barack Obama’s ambassador to NATO, wrote on Substack.

The Ukrainians used their agency. And the Europeans are using theirs as well.

And so apparently ends the latest chapter of what The Bulwark’s Cathy Young aptly calls the Trump administration’s “fake negotiations” to end the war on Putin’s terms.

After the last round of those talks in Abu Dhabi, the Russian side demanded that Ukraine cede territory it still holds and sharply reduce its armed forces. It also demanded a ban on not just NATO membership but any Western defense assistance, a rollback of NATO to its 1997 membership, and a prohibition on France and Britain extending their nuclear deterrents to other European nations.

Young described Russia’s demands as “so bold, one might think Russian troops had already steamrolled over Kyiv and Warsaw and were powering their way toward Berlin.”

International relations scholar Daniel Drezner, academic dean at The Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University, was just as biting. “Needless to say, Putin’s chutzpah is considerable,” Drezner wrote in his excellent Substack newsletter. “It takes…something to launch a war that everyone believed would only take a few weeks to complete, get bogged down, lose a lot of territory that was initially taken, face continued reverses on the battlefield, suffer appalling losses, lose the tactical advantage, and nonetheless insist on more imperial demands.”

Putin is losing the war on the battlefield and was clearly hoping to win at the table what he couldn’t take by force, by hoodwinking Trump and his handpicked negotiators, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner (whom Young memorably describes as “the two stooges”), into forcing Ukraine to cede it. As I wrote in this space, it was a classic KGB-style “reflexive control” operation. And it appears to have failed for the moment for the simple reason that Ukraine has a say in the matter.


Putin’s other play, of course, is to wear down Ukraine’s resolve with his relentless aerial assaults on civilians and the energy grid as winter approaches. But as awful — and criminal — as that is, my money is on Ukrainian resilience.

It can’t be repeated enough that given Russia’s eliminationist goals in Ukraine, there is no negotiated settlement to be had. The quickest, and only, way to end this war is to make sure Ukraine wins it. Period.

Brian Whitmore

Brian Whitmore

Brian Whitmore is a nonresident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council Eurasia Center, an assistant professor of practice at the University of Texas-Arlington, and host of The Power Vertical Podcast.

Recommended

Волкер
Interview

Volker: Trump Administration Has Let Moscow Shift Talks From Stopping Russia’s War to Europe’s Security Architecture

November 17, 2026
Росія Вірменія
Spotlight

Commentary: Goodbye, Yerevan — Russian Rift With Armenia Highlights Lost Influence In former Soviet Space

November 16, 2026
дрон
Interview

Every Drone Order From Russia and Ukraine Tells China How the War Is Evolving

November 12, 2026
logo-dark

To provide clarity in a complex world through fact-based storytelling about American policy, politics, and society.

Quick Navigation

  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Our Board
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
Donate Now

© 2026 Independence Avenue Media

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • English
    • English
    • ქართული
    • Українська
    • Русский
  • Home
  • USA
  • Interview
  • Deep Dive
  • Forged by War
  • Diaspora
  • Video

© 2026 Independence Avenue Media